While Pirelli offers a solid range of tires, the Scorpion AT Plus currently stands as its primary and most popular all-terrain option. While the Italian manufacturer produces high-performance road tires that set industry standards, the all-terrain segment is highly competitive. The Scorpion AT Plus is well-regarded for its balance between on-road refinement and trail capability, sporting an irregular, symmetrical tread pattern that earns it an impressive 93% best-in-class rating.
However, many other tires in this category manage to outperform the Scorpion AT Plus in critical areas, such as off-road traction, tread life, or specialized on-road comfort. Here are 12 all-terrain tires that boast higher ratings and offer superior performance.
1. BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A K03
The K03 is the latest evolution in the iconic BFGoodrich lineup. Boasting a 100% best-in-class rating, it offers a more balanced profile than its predecessors. Its interlocking tread blocks provide exceptional stability, while Baja-derived technology reinforces the sidewalls against trail hazards.
2. Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac RT
A true contender for the top spot, the DuraTrac RT features DuPont Kevlar integration and Durawall technology for extreme durability. With a 100% rating, it excels in both dry road handling and off-road scenarios, making it a favorite for full-size trucks and SUVs.
3. Bridgestone Dueler A/T Ascent
If your priority is on-road comfort without sacrificing loose-surface capability, this tire is a top choice. It also holds a 100% best-in-category rating. Its uniform symmetrical pattern and 3D siping technology ensure a quiet ride on the highway while maintaining excellent grip off the pavement.
4. Continental TerrainContact A/T
A long-time industry favorite, this tire remains a top performer, particularly in wet and dry on-road conditions. It utilizes TractionPlus technology to deliver class-leading wet braking performance, making it highly responsive for daily driving.
5. Nitto Ridge Grappler
For those needing a more aggressive look and capability, the Ridge Grappler is ideal. It matches the Scorpion AT Plus in overall scores but offers significantly better off-road traction. Its design features unique lateral Z-grooves to handle difficult terrain effectively.
6. General Grabber X3
As a more extreme, mud-terrain-focused option, the Grabber X3 earns a 98% rating. Its massive, high-void shoulder blocks make it exceptionally capable on loose trails, and it maintains surprising composure on paved surfaces despite its aggressive appearance.
7. Falken WildPeak A/T4W
This is one of the most well-rounded tires available, offering a 98% rating and a 65,000-mile tread warranty. The Duraspec sidewall protection and interlocking tread design make it both durable and versatile for varied climates and towing duties.
8. Toyo Open Country III
With over 8.5 million miles of tracked user experience, the Open Country III holds a 97% best-in-category rating. It strikes an excellent balance between price and performance, featuring wide lateral grooves for effective debris ejection and strong grip on loose surfaces.
9. Kumho Road Venture AT52
Matching the Scorpion AT Plus in on-road ability, the AT52 improves upon the formula with superior comfort and tread life. Its five-pitch design ensures a consistent, quiet contact patch, and it is generally more affordable than the Pirelli.
10. BFGoodrich Trail-Terrain T/A
Marketed specifically for those who spend more time on the tarmac but still want light off-road capability, this tire earns a 96% rating. It prioritizes low road noise and long tread life, featuring a design optimized for dry performance and comfort.
11. Cooper Discoverer AT3 XLT
This tire is designed for longevity and towing stability, featuring Cooper’s Even Wear Arc technology. With a 97% rating and a 60,000-mile warranty, it is a highly reliable choice for drivers who demand consistent performance under heavy loads.
12. Firestone Destination X/T
Occupying the same niche as the Scorpion AT Plus, the Destination X/T offers a more aggressive tread layout with deeper biting edges. It earns a 95% rating, providing an excellent balance of rugged off-road ability and reliable on-road tread wear.
Methodology
This list was compiled by analyzing a combination of consumer ratings from databases like Tire Rack—which breaks down specific performance metrics—and professional evaluations from reputable automotive outlets.